VodkapunditVodkapunditVodkapundit
Dhimmitude Or Diaspora?
Posted by Will Collier  ·  18 January 2005

Something's been bothering me since reading Christopher Caldwell's piece on the Netherlands in the wake of Theo van Gogh's murder. It's this bit:

The question naturally arises: If immigrants behave this way now, what will happen when they are far more numerous, as all authorities have long promised they will be? It has been estimated that the country's two largest cities, Amsterdam and Rotterdam, will be "majority minority" very soon (Rotterdam is today at 47 percent), and already 65 percent of primary and secondary students in both cities are of non-Dutch parentage. London's Daily Telegraph, citing immigration experts and government statistics, reported a net outflow of 13,000 people from Holland in the first six months of 2004, the first such deficit in half a century. One must treat this statistic carefully--it could be an artifact of an aging population in which many are retiring to warmer places. But it could also be the beginning of something resembling the American suburban phenomenon of "white flight," occurring at the level of an entire country.

What if a considerable fraction--even a large minority--of that 13,000 really are fleeing from Islamic radicalism? What happens 20 or 30 years from now, when demographic trends could well result in "minority-majority" (or even outright majority) status for the Islamic cohort in western Europe? If they're faced with the options of dhimmitude or flight, where will the native Europeans flee to?

Why, here, of course.

Lots will go to Canada, I would guess particularly the Scandinavians, and plenty more will go to Australia. But the majority will be drawn right here to the USA. After all, we've got more room, more money, more opportunities--and most importantly, we're the most able to protect our own. Not unlike their ancestors' cousins of past centuries, the majority of those who give up on Europe will come here.

And then what? What will we do with them? More interestingly, what will they do to us? Will the 'blue states' fill up with UNphilic Euro-refugees and get bluer? Or will the refugees, haven been driven from their homes by radical Islam, lean more towards the 'red' Scots-Irish motto of nemo me impune lacessit?

I don't have any idea. You don't, either. It's silly to even project current political trends in this country 20 years from now. In 1985, the South was still a province of the Democratic Party at virtually every level below the Presidency, and California was reliably Republican. Nobody really knows what the political maps will look like in 2025, much less how those maps might be impacted by a new wave of European immigrants.

But somebody ought to start thinking about it, both here, and across the pond. Just in case Holland is the canary in Europe's coal mine.

Comments

There's no "just in case" necessary... Holland is the canary, for sure.

How odd to think of Rotterdam, with its perennially damp air and boxy 1950s architecture becoming an Islamic city. I can't think of a place less like the Middle East, but obviously the immigration is more a factor of the culture than the climate.

Posted by: Joan at January 18, 2005 07:58 PM

They'll all become Scots-Irish. It's predestined.

Posted by: The Parson at January 18, 2005 08:02 PM

Interesting piece you've got there, Will. . .

My first thought, though, was not about how exodus from an increasingly orthodox europe would affect the American political food chain, but about voting blocks in two of the worlds most prominent Nuclear powers-if über-orthodox muslims form a sizeable group and begin wielding their political power in Nuclear Britain and Nuclear France, we will have far more disconcerting items at hand than liberal Hollanders moving to Wisconsin.

The Ghosts of the Muslim invasion of Europe that began in 711A.D. have come back to finish the job. . . Van Gogh's death will long be remembered as the opening barrage in what looks to be a long, drawn-out culture war. . .

Posted by: Foster at January 18, 2005 08:08 PM

Damn! My last post was DARK!

I formally apologize for being a downer and offer this as tribute:

http://www.scrappleface.com/MT/archives/002032.html

Posted by: Foster at January 18, 2005 08:12 PM

Stephen,
I think the major point being missed in all this angst regarding immigrants and immigration is the "assimilation factor".
Old Europe has never assimilated it's huge ingress of, mostly Mid-East, peoples into it's culture nor it's political system.
However, until the late 20th Century, the USA worked hard to assimilate those emigrating here.
Now, however, we seem to be emulating the failed European paradigm, with much effort being expended to keep, legal and non-legal, immigrants in their own lanuguage/ cultural ghettoes. this effort, of course, being led, financed, and politicized by the so-called Progressive Left.
I'm certain, given the intellectual superiority of most of vodka's readers, there will be, hopefully, many more eloquent and erudite comments on this paradigm.
BTW, a blogger who is almost a rightward antithesis of Vodka's libertarian leanings, self described theo-con Orrin Judd has been blogging on the USA immigrant issue for quite a few years.
If you follow the Bros Judd copy/paste link below, you must read the comments.
Mike Daley

http://www.brothersjudd.com/blog/archives/019628.html

Orrin's closing comment:
"Other than race, why would Republicans turn such folk away?"

Posted by: Mike Daley at January 18, 2005 08:44 PM

Will,
Mea Culpa for addressing previous to Martini Boy rather than you.
Mike

Posted by: Mike Daley at January 18, 2005 08:47 PM

It is so hard to project 20 years in advance, but Pat Buchanon's book "Death of the West" a couple years ago forecast just this very problem, what is going to happen in a Arabized Europe? Between massive immigration, and a birthrate below replacement, Europe has it has been for hundreds of years will cease to exist by the middle of this century. It is very possible that many will make the trek over the Atlantic, and I would think, would not want to make the mistake they did in Europe. However, their children probably will.

Posted by: Carl at January 18, 2005 09:57 PM

I don't have any idea. You don't, either.

I have an advantage you don't- my dad's side of the family are immigrants.

Those not inclined to a Nemo me impune lacessit attitude will go elsewhere- Canada or New Zealand, most likely. Those who are, will come here.

This is not new, it has been going on for some time. Kim Du Toit is only one example...

Posted by: rosignol at January 18, 2005 10:25 PM

If they're faced with the options of dhimmitude or flight, where will the native Europeans flee to?

Why, here, of course.

Are we willing to give them all green cards? If not, that could put a hitch in their plans. The Atlantic's a lot harder to swim across than the Rio Grande.

Posted by: Zebediah at January 18, 2005 10:32 PM

The French? Here? Anyone else think a "No Vacancy" sign hanging on Lady Liberty looks more and more attractive? ;)

Posted by: Nick at January 19, 2005 07:22 AM

The stage was set during the 60's and 70's. Mullti-culturism and hyphenated-Americans replaced the melting pot and just plain Americans.

Perhaps 30 or 40 years of Republican admdinistrations can reverse this unhappy state of affairs.

My questions which I haven't seen asnwered anywhere is: Why are all these Muslims emigrating? Muslim countries are for the most part socialist theocracies. Why leave these paradaisical warm homelands for cold climes where there still are some vestiges of democracy and capitalism?

Posted by: erp at January 19, 2005 08:20 AM

There are currently some 480 million citizens of European Union states. 15 million are Muslims.

In the Netherlands 91% of the population is ethnic Dutch, Muslims 4%.
The total population under 14 is 18%.
So majority of schoolkids Muslim? I don't think so.
The Muslim population is heavily concentrated in a few urban centres: thats why they show up in schools for (inner) Amsterdam and Rotterdam.

Or take France as an example.
Current Muslim population c.7%
IF current rates of Muslim increase (immigration and reproduction combined)continue at 2% per annum
AND non-Muslims decline at 0.5% per annum
THEN after 50 years Muslim population is 20% of total, after roughly a century 50%.

Both assumptions are unlikely. Immigrant decendant birthrates almost always fall off from initial levels.

Demographic takeover isn't the problem, short to medium-term anyhow.
What is the problem is a (possibly growing) minority of militants within a larger number of poorly-assimilated, welfare-oriented second or third generation Muslims. A fertile recruitment and operational environment for jihadis.

The best likely to be dropping multicultural nonsense, insisting upon assimilation, and draining the urban crime/welfare swamps.
BTW, France had a good record of asimilating immigrants (Poles, Spanish, Italians, Portuguese) 1850/1950.

Posted by: John F at January 19, 2005 10:01 AM

Why are all these Muslims emigrating?

Most are fleeing the theocracies, but others are following along to try to keep the mullahs in control. I'd bet they think of it as "jihad by demographics."

Posted by: McGehee at January 19, 2005 10:05 AM

The French? Here? Anyone else think a "No Vacancy" sign hanging on Lady Liberty looks more and more attractive?

Oh, given that our culture tends to be so contagious, surely we have room for some of them.

Posted by: Ash at January 19, 2005 10:21 AM

I have blogged on this a lot this past week - and been linked to on it by chrenkoff, among others. Here're the links -

Me on the new emigres leaving Europe:

http://astuteblogger.blogspot.com/2005/01/eu-needs-thatcher-now.html

Me on the islamification of France:

http://astuteblogger.blogspot.com/2005/01/par-is-tanbul.html

Me with more - much more - on the islamification of France:

http://astuteblogger.blogspot.com/2005/01/mosque-de-notre-dame.html

Posted by: reliapundit at January 19, 2005 03:20 PM



Navigation

MDS - Give Until It Hurts

Terror War Scorecard
Watching America

50 Things
American Cancer Ablation Center
Buy VodkaPundit Stuff



VodkaPundit on Amazon
Vodkapundit for PDA (AvantGo)
Vodkapundit for PDA (Not)
VodkaPundit XML or RDF

Search



Advanced Search



Last Call

The Author

"If Janeane Garofalo had ever met VodkaPundit, she'd be Anne Coulter by now."
-Venomous Kate

Absolut Link

Blog-Iran

Top Shelf

Ann Althouse
Baldilocks
Austin Bay
Belmont Club
Tim Blair
Chequer Board
Command Post
Counterterrorism Blog
Day By Day
Daniel Drezner
From the Bleachers
Hit & Run
INDC Journal
Iraq the Model
James Joyner
James Lileks
Megan McArdle
OPFOR
Protein Wisdom
Glenn Reynolds
Bill Roggio
ScreedBlog
Roger L. Simon
Rob Smith
Steven Taylor
Venomous Kate
Matt Welch
Winds of Change
Michael Yon
Yuppies of Zion


The Usual

Across the Atlantic
Anticipatory Retaliation
Atlas Shrugs
The Black Republican
Blogcritics
Captain's Quarters
Phil Carter
The Daily Ablution
Andrew Ian Dodge
Eye on the Left
Mike Hendrix
In From the Cold
Charles Johnson
Kathy Kinsley
A Likely Story
Brian Linse
Jay Manifold
Neocon News
Frank Martin
QandO
Bill Quick
Rantburg
John Scalzi
Sine Qua Non Pundit
Team Stryker
Mac Thomason
Michael Totten
Jesse Walker
Dr. Weevil
Bill Whittle
Chief Wiggles
Sissy Willis
Cathy Young

Micro Brews

American Realpolitik
Black Five
Boots and Sabers
Capitalist Lion
Scott Chaffin
John Cole
Coming Anarchy
Bo Cowgill
Dr. Frank's Blogs of War
Donklephant
Ed Driscoll
Kim du Toit
Glenn Frazier
Joe Gandleman
The Gay Patriot
Godless Capitalist
Bill Hobbs
John Hudock
Frank J.'s IMAO
Joanne Jacobs
Brothers Judd
Junk Yard Blog
Major John
Davids Medienkritik
Mr. Misha's Rottweiler
Only Baseball Matters
Matt Moore
Jack O'Toole
Peaktalk
Eric S. Raymond
Red Sugar
Resurrection Song
Robin Roberts
Andrea See
Mathew Sheren
Spoons Experience
DC Thornton
Yankee Station

Gin & Tonic

Albion's Seedlings
American Digest
Radley Balko
Paul Berger
Robert Bidinotto
Blogometer
BusinessPundit
The Chicago Boyz
Classical Values
Conrad the Expat
Susanna Cornett
Dave Cullen
England's Sword
Dean Esmay
Horsefeathers
Jessica's Well
Alex Knapp
Legal Spin
Light of Reason
The Lipstick Republican
Moxie
OxBlog
Suman Palit
Punch the Bag
The Pursuit of Happiness
Samizdata
Sofia Sideshow
Natalie Solent
Texas Best Grok
Professor Michael Tinkler
Cal Ulmann
Brothers Volokh

Cosmopolitans

Justene Adamec
Stephen Bainbridge
La Shawn Barber
Moira Breen
Sasha Castel
Colorado Psycho
Clayton Cramer
CrossingWallStreet
Martin Devon
Kevin Drum
Henry Hanks
Diana Hsieh
Jeff Jarvis
Jessica
Sean Kirby
Liberty Belles
Rachel Lucas
Jeralyn Merritt
Philip Murphy
Oasis of Sanity
Andrew Olmsted
Walter Olson
Michael Parker
Popped Culture
Porphyrogenitus
Fritz Schrank
Donald Sensing
Elizabeth Spiers
The Swanky Conservative
Two Blowhards
Michael Ubaldi
Alexandra von Maltzan
Will Wilkinson

Rum & Coke

The Argument Clinic
Below the Beltway
The Bitch Girls
Jay Caruso
Dog's Life
Fire On The Mountain
GeckoBlue
GZ Expat
David Hogberg
John Hawkins
Horologium
Kris Lofgren
Floyd McWilliams
John Moore
PhotoDude
Robyn Pollman
Chas Rich
Silflay Hraka
Geitner Simmons
Skippy
Dave Tepper
Transterrestrial Musings
Trying to Grok
Walter in Denver
Don Watkins
Weekend Pundit
Joshua Zader

Tequila Shots

Todd A
N.Z. Bear
Begging to Differ
David MSC
Gary Farber
Highered Intelligence
Isntapundit
Jonathan and Wanda
Ken Layne
Nick Marsala
Dan Michalski
Sheila O'Malley
Dawn Olsen
Tony Pierce
Raving Atheist
Matt Traylor
Sekimori
WMET Blog
World Wide Rant

Manischewitz

Moe Freedman
Tal G. in Jerusalem
IsraPundit
Kesher Talk
Mike Silverman
Allison Kaplan Sommer
Meryl Yourish

Boozehounds

Allah Is In the House
Dave Barry's Blog
The Daily Sedative
Doug Dever
Daniel Frank
Scott Ott
Large American Penis
Short Strange Trip
Ten Fingers, Six Strings
Jim Treacher

Cyanide-Laced Kool-Aid

Laurence Simon

Sex on the Beach

Body in Mind
ErosBlog
Eroticalee
Just One Bite
Fred Lapides
New York Hotties
SLA
Unablogger

Kegger

Ben Domenech
HokiePundit
Hoosier Review
John Tabin
Nicholas West

Fosters

Duck Season
Mike Jericho
John Ray
Bernard Slattery
Whacking Day

Molson

Banana Counting Monkey
Daimnation!
Dispatches
David Janes
Western Standard

Left Wing Bar Nuts

Ted Barlow
Joshua Marshall
Dan Perkins

Cover Charge

Eric Alterman
Dave Barry
Barone Blog
Austin Bay
Jay Bryant
C-Log
Campaign Desk
Steve Chapman
Dallas News Blog
Matt Drudge
Google News
Nat Henthoff
Hugh Hewitt
Mickey Kaus
Howard Kurtz
National Review Online
The New Republic
The New York Times
Newsweek
OpinionJournal
Kathleen Parker
Daniel Pipes
Virginia Postrel
Roll Call
Larry Sabato
Linda Seebach
Slate
Sploid
Mark Steyn
StrategyPage
Andrew Sullivan
Tapped
Tech Central Station
Time
US News & World Report
David Warren
The Washington Post

Under the Table

American Times
Angry Left
Asparagirl
BitchPundit
John Braue
Shiloh Bucher
Carthaginian Peace
Lorenzo Cortes
Steven Den Beste
Fevered Rants
Scott "Funkadelic" Ganz
Juan Gato
Happy Fun Pundit
Andrea Harris
Scott Koenig
Brink Lindsey
Sue Lizano
Kieran Lyons
Mean Mr. Mustard
Meeshness
Punditwatch
Dennis Rogers
Jim Ryan
Spinsanity
Unremitting Verse
Norah Vincent
Tony Woodlief

Archives

Powered by Movable TypeDesign by Sekimori