VodkapunditVodkapunditVodkapundit
"Yep, The Critics Are Right. Now, I'm Outta Here!"
Posted by Will Collier  ·  25 July 2004

Astonishing final column from New York Times "Public Editor" Daniel Okrent today (as noted by Ed Driscoll and the Blogfaddah):

Is the New York Times a liberal newspaper?

Of course it is.

[snip]

[I]if you're examining the paper's coverage of these subjects from a perspective that is neither urban nor Northeastern nor culturally seen-it-all; if you are among the groups The Times treats as strange objects to be examined on a laboratory slide (devout Catholics, gun owners, Orthodox Jews, Texans); if your value system wouldn't wear well on a composite New York Times journalist, then a walk through this paper can make you feel you're traveling in a strange and forbidding world.

Start with the editorial page, so thoroughly saturated in liberal theology that when it occasionally strays from that point of view the shocked yelps from the left overwhelm even the ceaseless rumble of disapproval from the right.

[snip]

But opinion pages are opinion pages, and "balanced opinion page" is an oxymoron. So let's move elsewhere. In the Sunday magazine, the culture-wars applause-o-meter chronically points left. On the Arts & Leisure front page every week, columnist Frank Rich slices up President Bush, Mel Gibson, John Ashcroft and other paladins of the right in prose as uncompromising as Paul Krugman's or Maureen Dowd's. The culture pages often feature forms of art, dance or theater that may pass for normal (or at least tolerable) in New York but might be pretty shocking in other places.

Same goes for fashion coverage, particularly in the Sunday magazine, where I've encountered models who look like they're preparing to murder (or be murdered), and others arrayed in a mode you could call dominatrix chic. If you're like Jim Chapman, one of my correspondents who has given up on The Times, you're lost in space. Wrote Chapman, "Whatever happened to poetry that required rhyme and meter, to songs that required lyrics and tunes, to clothing ads that stressed the costume rather than the barely clothed females and slovenly dressed, slack-jawed, unshaven men?"

The kicker? Okrent is leaving his post as of this column. He wasn't clear as to whether he's coming back or not, although he did make a reference to commenting about the Times' politics and policy coverage after the election--wow, that'll be helpful to voters, won't it? What a dereliction by Okrent, or by his bosses, if this departure wan't his idea.

So much for reform at the Times. As IP noted a day or two ago, no wonder the company's stock is scraping bottom. They won't even listen to their own pallid reformers.

UPDATE: As a reader notes, I didn't pay sufficient attention to Okrent's sign-off, in which he promises to return after Labor Day. Bad on me; Reading Is Fundamental.

Comments

Dude, you should have read to the end. He is not leaving.

    I'm going to spend August in a deck chair and see if I can once again read The Times like a civilian. See you after Labor Day

    Posted by: Donut at July 25, 2004 09:01 AM

    His brain will explode.

    Posted by: Sandy P at July 25, 2004 11:58 AM

    Funny thing:

    Several friends of mine read that send-off by Okrent, and we all see it as a thinly veiled departure letter, i.e., we don't think he'll be back.

    Any chance that Keller and company will accept his resignation on account of poor health/time with family/book deal/offer from another paper or magazine?

    Posted by: Dean at July 25, 2004 12:26 PM

    I sit here stunned by Mr. Okrent's words. I nearly had to pick my jaw off the floor. Way to unload Mr. Okrent! Let me add a "Here! Here!" for him too.

    Hats off the the NYT for printing it. LOL

    Posted by: RandMan at July 25, 2004 01:26 PM

    The only things I remember reading from the NYT that I would consider not biased to the left is OP-ED contributions from William Safire and David Brooks, which I would say are biased to the right.

    I always read the Times anyway to keep up on what the "Enemy"(Nyuk, Nyuk!) is up to. They do do some great investigational reporting on gov't agencies waste, incompetence, and cover-ups that make all blood types boil.

    Posted by: Jim Russell at July 25, 2004 02:21 PM

    The substitute readers' rep is a 25yr. editor of NYT?

    Posted by: Stephen Benbow at July 25, 2004 04:10 PM

    I thought Mr. Okrent displayed a superb grasp of the stunningly obvious. Then again, even small steps forward mean progress.

    Posted by: Richard DiNardo at July 25, 2004 07:04 PM

    ...followed by big steps as Mr. Okrent beats feet for the beach...

    Posted by: P.A. Breault at July 25, 2004 07:57 PM

    My personal favorite line was his use of the term, Liberal Theology.
    Because that's what it has become. A theology. As such, you cannot question its central tenets or you will be apostate, (see Bjorn Lomborg).
    I too wonder if he will have a job when he comes back. Not if he tries to pen another of these columns.

    Posted by: Veeshir at July 26, 2004 06:19 AM



    Navigation

    MDS - Give Until It Hurts

    Terror War Scorecard
    Watching America

    50 Things
    American Cancer Ablation Center
    Buy VodkaPundit Stuff



    VodkaPundit on Amazon
    Vodkapundit for PDA (AvantGo)
    Vodkapundit for PDA (Not)
    VodkaPundit XML or RDF

    Search



    Advanced Search



    Last Call

    The Author

    "Mordant wit and stylish cynicism."
    -James Lileks

    Absolut Link

    Blog-Iran

    Top Shelf

    Ann Althouse
    Baldilocks
    Austin Bay
    Belmont Club
    Tim Blair
    Chequer Board
    Command Post
    Counterterrorism Blog
    Day By Day
    Daniel Drezner
    From the Bleachers
    Hit & Run
    INDC Journal
    Iraq the Model
    James Joyner
    James Lileks
    Megan McArdle
    OPFOR
    Protein Wisdom
    Glenn Reynolds
    Bill Roggio
    ScreedBlog
    Roger L. Simon
    Rob Smith
    Steven Taylor
    Venomous Kate
    Matt Welch
    Winds of Change
    Michael Yon
    Yuppies of Zion


    The Usual

    Across the Atlantic
    Anticipatory Retaliation
    Atlas Shrugs
    The Black Republican
    Blogcritics
    Captain's Quarters
    Phil Carter
    The Daily Ablution
    Andrew Ian Dodge
    Eye on the Left
    Mike Hendrix
    In From the Cold
    Charles Johnson
    Kathy Kinsley
    A Likely Story
    Brian Linse
    Jay Manifold
    Neocon News
    Frank Martin
    QandO
    Bill Quick
    Rantburg
    John Scalzi
    Sine Qua Non Pundit
    Team Stryker
    Mac Thomason
    Michael Totten
    Jesse Walker
    Dr. Weevil
    Bill Whittle
    Chief Wiggles
    Sissy Willis
    Cathy Young

    Micro Brews

    American Realpolitik
    Black Five
    Boots and Sabers
    Capitalist Lion
    Scott Chaffin
    John Cole
    Coming Anarchy
    Bo Cowgill
    Dr. Frank's Blogs of War
    Donklephant
    Ed Driscoll
    Kim du Toit
    Glenn Frazier
    Joe Gandleman
    The Gay Patriot
    Godless Capitalist
    Bill Hobbs
    John Hudock
    Frank J.'s IMAO
    Joanne Jacobs
    Brothers Judd
    Junk Yard Blog
    Major John
    Davids Medienkritik
    Mr. Misha's Rottweiler
    Only Baseball Matters
    Matt Moore
    Jack O'Toole
    Peaktalk
    Eric S. Raymond
    Red Sugar
    Resurrection Song
    Robin Roberts
    Andrea See
    Mathew Sheren
    Spoons Experience
    DC Thornton
    Yankee Station

    Gin & Tonic

    Albion's Seedlings
    American Digest
    Radley Balko
    Paul Berger
    Robert Bidinotto
    Blogometer
    BusinessPundit
    The Chicago Boyz
    Classical Values
    Conrad the Expat
    Susanna Cornett
    Dave Cullen
    England's Sword
    Dean Esmay
    Horsefeathers
    Jessica's Well
    Alex Knapp
    Legal Spin
    Light of Reason
    The Lipstick Republican
    Moxie
    OxBlog
    Suman Palit
    Punch the Bag
    The Pursuit of Happiness
    Samizdata
    Sofia Sideshow
    Natalie Solent
    Texas Best Grok
    Professor Michael Tinkler
    Cal Ulmann
    Brothers Volokh

    Cosmopolitans

    Justene Adamec
    Stephen Bainbridge
    La Shawn Barber
    Moira Breen
    Sasha Castel
    Colorado Psycho
    Clayton Cramer
    CrossingWallStreet
    Martin Devon
    Kevin Drum
    Henry Hanks
    Diana Hsieh
    Jeff Jarvis
    Jessica
    Sean Kirby
    Liberty Belles
    Rachel Lucas
    Jeralyn Merritt
    Philip Murphy
    Oasis of Sanity
    Andrew Olmsted
    Walter Olson
    Michael Parker
    Popped Culture
    Porphyrogenitus
    Fritz Schrank
    Donald Sensing
    Elizabeth Spiers
    The Swanky Conservative
    Two Blowhards
    Michael Ubaldi
    Alexandra von Maltzan
    Will Wilkinson

    Rum & Coke

    The Argument Clinic
    Below the Beltway
    The Bitch Girls
    Jay Caruso
    Dog's Life
    Fire On The Mountain
    GeckoBlue
    GZ Expat
    David Hogberg
    John Hawkins
    Horologium
    Kris Lofgren
    Floyd McWilliams
    John Moore
    PhotoDude
    Robyn Pollman
    Chas Rich
    Silflay Hraka
    Geitner Simmons
    Skippy
    Dave Tepper
    Transterrestrial Musings
    Trying to Grok
    Walter in Denver
    Don Watkins
    Weekend Pundit
    Joshua Zader

    Tequila Shots

    Todd A
    N.Z. Bear
    Begging to Differ
    David MSC
    Gary Farber
    Highered Intelligence
    Isntapundit
    Jonathan and Wanda
    Ken Layne
    Nick Marsala
    Dan Michalski
    Sheila O'Malley
    Dawn Olsen
    Tony Pierce
    Raving Atheist
    Matt Traylor
    Sekimori
    WMET Blog
    World Wide Rant

    Manischewitz

    Moe Freedman
    Tal G. in Jerusalem
    IsraPundit
    Kesher Talk
    Mike Silverman
    Allison Kaplan Sommer
    Meryl Yourish

    Boozehounds

    Allah Is In the House
    Dave Barry's Blog
    The Daily Sedative
    Doug Dever
    Daniel Frank
    Scott Ott
    Large American Penis
    Short Strange Trip
    Ten Fingers, Six Strings
    Jim Treacher

    Cyanide-Laced Kool-Aid

    Laurence Simon

    Sex on the Beach

    Body in Mind
    ErosBlog
    Eroticalee
    Just One Bite
    Fred Lapides
    New York Hotties
    SLA
    Unablogger

    Kegger

    Ben Domenech
    HokiePundit
    Hoosier Review
    John Tabin
    Nicholas West

    Fosters

    Duck Season
    Mike Jericho
    John Ray
    Bernard Slattery
    Whacking Day

    Molson

    Banana Counting Monkey
    Daimnation!
    Dispatches
    David Janes
    Western Standard

    Left Wing Bar Nuts

    Ted Barlow
    Joshua Marshall
    Dan Perkins

    Cover Charge

    Eric Alterman
    Dave Barry
    Barone Blog
    Austin Bay
    Jay Bryant
    C-Log
    Campaign Desk
    Steve Chapman
    Dallas News Blog
    Matt Drudge
    Google News
    Nat Henthoff
    Hugh Hewitt
    Mickey Kaus
    Howard Kurtz
    National Review Online
    The New Republic
    The New York Times
    Newsweek
    OpinionJournal
    Kathleen Parker
    Daniel Pipes
    Virginia Postrel
    Roll Call
    Larry Sabato
    Linda Seebach
    Slate
    Sploid
    Mark Steyn
    StrategyPage
    Andrew Sullivan
    Tapped
    Tech Central Station
    Time
    US News & World Report
    David Warren
    The Washington Post

    Under the Table

    American Times
    Angry Left
    Asparagirl
    BitchPundit
    John Braue
    Shiloh Bucher
    Carthaginian Peace
    Lorenzo Cortes
    Steven Den Beste
    Fevered Rants
    Scott "Funkadelic" Ganz
    Juan Gato
    Happy Fun Pundit
    Andrea Harris
    Scott Koenig
    Brink Lindsey
    Sue Lizano
    Kieran Lyons
    Mean Mr. Mustard
    Meeshness
    Punditwatch
    Dennis Rogers
    Jim Ryan
    Spinsanity
    Unremitting Verse
    Norah Vincent
    Tony Woodlief

    Archives

    Powered by Movable TypeDesign by Sekimori