![]() ![]() ![]() |
|
Although I Do Still Have Trouble With the Whole Altercation Gig
Posted by Stephen Green · 5 February 2003
Jeralyn Merritt of TalkLeft, my favorite civil rights blog, answers this question from one of her readers: Just curious, why do you promote Instapundit and Vodkapundit? They are right-wing oriented and 180 degrees from you? One might as well ask why a blogg-thirsty warblogger such as myself promotes Jeralyn, but I'll let her answer first. Read: Norm, that's a very good question, and probably a lot of people have wondered about this. The reason we promote Instapundit is because we agree on several issues that are of importance to us. I'd like to thank Jeralyn for her many fine words. If nothing else, this site aims to entertain and amuse -- although the more rabid left-wingers might need to take VodkaPundit with a chaser. As for civil rights, you'll find I'm probably more in agreement with Jeralyn than not, although I haven't seen anything in the current administration any worse than, oh... anyone since Jefferson. Ashcroft? I think the nicest thing I ever said about him was last week, when I stated my preference for a "Demoral-laced Norm Mineta" over Uptight John. And I'm still against the death penalty, although for strictly utilitarian reasons. The Consitution is 100% clear that it envisions a death penalty, so I can't agree with any notion that it isn't constitutional. However, with an imperfect (ie, human) judicial system, I can't be in favor of a sentence that can't be commuted. But enough of that. Why do I link to Jeralyn? Because, whatever our disagreements, she is first and foremost a staunch defender of many of those rights I hold dear -- a well-spoken, persuasive, and attractive defender at that. I'd link to her more often, but me not being trained in the law, her issues usually aren't my own. On any given issue, you take your allies where you find them. You take your friends there, too. Comments
Right on, VP. Anyone who is after the truth and not too shabby at finding it should be listened to by anyone who fits the same description. If you don't link only because of deep disagreement, then you don't fit that description. And that means you either don't care about the truth or aren't good at finding it. Posted by: Jim at February 5, 2003 03:58 PMStephen, I stand happily corrected on your death penalty and Ashcroft positions--and I thank you for your kind remarks. Your friend, Jeralyn Posted by: Jeralyn at February 5, 2003 04:01 PMI've been wrestling with how to summarize my own political beliefs and the best way I can describe it is that I want the Dems out of my wallet and the GOP out of my bedroom.....I have to say that I am in favor of the death penalty in that it does take the intransigent cri,inal out of the game so to speak but I do also worry about the fallibility of our (human) justice system. Steven I really enjoy your BLOG next time I make the journey to Denver I'd love to stop in your neck of the woods and buy you a nice dry Grey Goose Martini Posted by: Kent at February 5, 2003 06:55 PMI think the underlying assumption here is off for several reasons. First, linking to someone or citing their views on any issue is not the same as supporting them. And second, anyone with intellectual honesty or curiosity ought to be linking with and promoting opposing voices, at least those that are willing to engage in reasonable discussions and present interesting cases and ideas. If you're not actually engaging with the ideas of those who disagree with you, you're wasting your own time as well as everyone else's. Preaching to the choir might be fun, and if you write for the Nation or the American Prospect it can be profitable too, but it's still an ulitmately worthless enterprise. And there's far too much of it going on in the blogosphere, in my opinion. Posted by: Doug Turnbull at February 6, 2003 09:16 AM |
MDS - Give Until It Hurts Terror War Scorecard Watching America 50 Things American Cancer Ablation Center Buy VodkaPundit Stuff
"His hair was perfect."
Ann Althouse
Across the Atlantic
American Realpolitik
Albion's Seedlings
Justene Adamec
The Argument Clinic
Todd A
Moe Freedman
Allah Is In the House
Body in Mind
Ben Domenech
Duck Season
Banana Counting Monkey
Ted Barlow
Eric Alterman
American Times
|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |