![]() ![]() ![]() |
|
History Repeats Itself?
Posted by Stephen Green · 5 February 2003
Anne Applebaum points out that Germany’s newfound crankiness isn’t just about Iraq: Although it sounds like pacifism, Schroeder's rhetoric seems to be part of a larger pattern of assertiveness. When he came to office, he spoke of his desire to make Germany a "normal" country, liberated from its past. Now his countrymen seem determined to take him up on it. Last spring, a handful of German and Austrian conservative politicians tried to revive the long-dead question of compensation for Germans expelled from the Czech Republic at the end of the war -- an issue that many felt had been settled. Recently a debate over whether the Allied bombing of Dresden was a war crime has preoccupied the German press. Speaking of Dresden, one German historian called on the British to face up to their past -- something many have long asked of Germany. Germans complain louder than they did in the past about the unfairness of European Union budgets, which have always been supported by German taxpayers, and they have grown more assertive in their demands for German influence within the European Union itself. Let’s re-write that graf a wee bit: Although it sounds like militarism, Chancellor Hitler’s rhetoric seems to be part of an even larger pattern of assertiveness. When he came to office, he shouted of his desire to make Germany a “normal” country, liberated from its past. Now his countrymen seem determined to take him up on it. Last spring, a handful of German and Austrian conservative politicians tried to revive the long-dead question of compensation for Germans expelled from Polish lands at the end of the Great War – an issue that many felt had been settled. Recently a debate over whether the British naval “starvation” blockade of German harbors was a war crime has preoccupied the German press. Speaking of the blockade, one German historian called on the British to face up to their past – something many have long asked of the Weimar Republic. Germans complain louder than they did in the past about the unfairness of Versailles Treaty reparations, which have been supported by German taxpayers, and have grown more assertive in their demands for German influence within the League of Nations. Of course, that’s probably a cheap bit of scare-mongering on my part. Schroeder hasn’t said one word about increasing German military readiness. Still, it’s a good thing our forces are in better shape now than they were in 1939, nicht wahr? Comments
But it's not 1939 yet. Not nearly. Its the '20s still. The French Army is still in the Ruhr. Err.. the U.S. is still in wherever. Posted by: Pete S. at February 4, 2003 11:32 PMAt the risk of breaking Godwin's Law, why is it that people are crazy enough to SERIOUSLY suggest that we can just sit on Iraq for, oh, another decade, and everything'll be hunky-dory?? Here were the Germans. Defeated (sort of) in World War I. Punitively punished. Economically crippled. Stripped, not only of Alsace-Lorraine, but also the Ruhr (occupied for a decade) and the Rhineland. Disarmed, not just of heavy artillery and battleships, but of everything heavier than a machine gun and limited to 100,000 troops. Better yet, two major empires who had suffered huge losses, and therefore had "the honored dead" to remind them of the need to sit on the Germans. And by the mid-1920s, they were breaking all the restrictions, clandestinely rearming, etc., etc., etc. By the early 1930s, when the bodies in the ground hadn't even completely rotted yet, the Anglo-French armies had been gutted, the politicians were intent on cutting defense spending, and nobody really cared when the Germans marched into the Rhineland. Now, do we REALLY think the Greens, the Left, etc., who were carping on the "inhumanity" of sanctions, are really gonna keep them up for ANOTHER decade? Sigh.... Posted by: Dean at February 5, 2003 07:57 AMWell speaking as a Brit, when it comes to looking our past in the face, maybe it's got a few warts. But any German with the bloody cheek to lecture us about it can bugger off. |
MDS - Give Until It Hurts Terror War Scorecard Watching America 50 Things American Cancer Ablation Center Buy VodkaPundit Stuff
"His hair was perfect."
Ann Althouse
Across the Atlantic
American Realpolitik
Albion's Seedlings
Justene Adamec
The Argument Clinic
Todd A
Moe Freedman
Allah Is In the House
Body in Mind
Ben Domenech
Duck Season
Banana Counting Monkey
Ted Barlow
Eric Alterman
American Times
|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |